M and J Firearms
                                           24 S. Main Street | Fortville, IN  46040

Reputable Gun Dealers
Gun enthusiasts Martin Peters and Jerry Kemna wanted more than just your average, run-of-the-mill gun store.  Opening in early 2012, their idealogy was to provide an uncluttered, friendly, positive, and safe environment for both the beginner as well as the expert gun owner.

M and J Firearms implements a low-pressure atmosphere in which anyone can come in and spend as much time as they need asking questions, examining firearms, and finding what is right for their specific needs.  When visiting the store customers feel welcome and respected.

We pride ourselves on going the extra mile to assist with nearly every firearm-related issue.  Our staff are all trained and certified NRA instructors each with a broad spectrum of experience in hunting, target practice, and competitive shooting sports.

Fortville's Central Location
Just minutes from Geist Reservoir!  Conveniently located between Indianapolis, Anderson, Fishers & Noblesville
| Mapquest |

If we don't have what you want, we will make every attempt to get it

>> Special orders always welcome <<

Store Hours

Tuesday - Friday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 7pm

Saturday 11am - 4pm


 Premium Weapons, Class 3 NFA Items, Ammo, & Accessories   

We will not sell counterfeit anything or unauthorized copies of weapons

We trade fairly

Buy | Sell | Trade | Consign

We must physically have the firearm in the store in order to Consign and Appraise.  
This absolutely cannot be done via email or over the phone.

 Insurance Appraisals
  • In store | single firearm | $10
  • Appointment necessary for more than one item
  • 317.747.4741
  • Contact Us
 Consignment Sales
  • Approximately 15-25% fee depending on item consigned
  • Consignor is eligible to retrieve the firearm at any time as long as they pass the same federal backgound check as the purchaser
  • $20 Fee may be associated with the retrieval depending upon the circumstance
  • If background check not passed, firearm remains at M and J until sold
Fortville Business District
24 S. Main Street


Website Builder